The Portrayal of the Trump-Putin Peace Summit in Budapest: A Comparative Analysis

-

Donald Trump’s recent announcement of an upcoming peace summit held in Budapest and hosted by PM Viktor Orbán has attracted significant media attention. As the trending event has triggered diametrically opposing views across various media outlets, it has become inevitable that their portrayal of it presents a stark contrast for their readers.

Therefore, the primary objective of this comparative analysis is to juxtapose three non-randomly chosen news articles on the subject: Reuters1, Hungary Today2, and The Telegraph3. This analysis purports to highlight the profound role the following aspects play in shaping the articles’ message. These aspects are linguistic framing, factual consistency, and emotional tone.

 

https://www.independent.ie/world-news/trump-says-he-will-meet-putin-for-second-time-in-hungary-to-try-to-resolve-russia-ukraine-war/a831185371.html


Linguistic framing and emotional tone:

The concept of the inverted pyramid and its three structural elements (lead, body, and tail) is reflected in composing the three news stories:

Considering the Reuters article, it opens with “When Russia's Vladimir Putin steps off the plane in European Union and NATO member Hungary for a summit with Donald Trump”. Adopting a neutral register enables Reuters to assume an analytical tone and remain impartial in describing the event. In the body section, it delves further into the context and presents facts to the readers and discusses the awkwardness of the meeting supported by quotes. The tail section extends the discussion to Hungarian domestic politics, which serves a peripheral role in the text.

In contrast to the distant tone of Reuters, The Telegraph article assumed a more right-leaning and opinionated tone. In the lead excerpt, it frames the meeting as a “huge boon” to PM Orbán and “a painful blow in Europe.” In the body section, the article continues to glorify Orbán as the bête noire of the EU, positioning him as a close friend and ally of the American president. Furthermore, Hungary’s Orbán is characterized as “a campaigner for peace”, which implies he assumes a dominant position at the joint peace conference between the two superpowers. In the tail section, the article winds up the subject with a quote from Donald Trump when he publicly commended Orbán for being such a great leader. This once again brings an ideological dimension through which one can perceive the event.

In parallel to the foreign press, Hungary Today also reported on the upcoming event. In the beginning, the article similarly elevates the status of Orbán and his ruling party, who warmly welcome Trump’s initiative. The several posts embedded from X consistently push their narrative. On the surface, each of these posts touches on national pride, which inherently evokes heightened emotions. In the end, the text states that the summit is “a major win for Orbán but a significant embarrassment for the EU”.


https://index.hu/belfold/2025/10/16/orban-viiktor-donald-trump-talalkozo/


Factual consistency:

Beyond claims driven by opinions, the articles also diverge greatly in factual transparency and bias:

In the Reuters article, most sources and quotations are taken from reliable sources. It discusses politically heated issues, such as the International Criminal Court's arrest warrant against President Putin. Historical references are also included when Reuters cites the Budapest Memorandum. The primary goal of the article is to provide the reader with a balanced overview of the event.

That said, The Telegraph and the Hungary Today articles merge factual analysis with identity politics. Although all three sources mostly rely on secondary sources, the latter two lack diversity. Both rely on selective quoting and exclusively represent right-leaning voices drawing on pro-government X and Facebook posts, thus omitting counter-narratives. Unlike the Hungary Today news, The Telegraph is less transparent about its sources. The ultimate goal of the two articles is not to question but to frame and persuade. None of the articles contains serious libel or misrepresentation.

Conclusion:

These three articles perfectly illustrate how different media outlets can construct diverging realities of the same event through linguistic framing, factual consistency, and emotional tone; the Trump-Putin peace summit is no exception to this.


Megjegyzések

Megjegyzés küldése

Népszerű bejegyzések ezen a blogon

Authorial Identity and Objectivity: A Hungarian EFL Perspective on Academic Writing

-
Kép
As students in higher education advance in their studies over the course of their university years, it becomes more and more crucial that they develop an authorial identity. However, in Hungarian tertiary education students are urged by their tutors they adopt an impersonal style in their written essays. Struggling to meet institutional standards, they cannot construct their own writerly identities. Nevertheless, an objective presentation of ideas does not necessarily prevent Hungarian EFL university students from incorporating their personalities into their writing. Therefore, Hungarian EFL students must be equipped with the linguistic devices to make their voices heard. This essay seeks to propose that the insistence on objectivity in English academic writing does not inhibit Hungarian EFL university students from assuming their academic writer identity. First, there have been several studies conducted that indicated that there is great room for individuality in academic writing. ...
Read more »

THBT Viktor Orban will decide not to run for PM in the 2026 Hungarian election

-
Kép
Motion: THBT Viktor Orban will decide not to run for PM in the 2026 Hungarian election. Proposition: PM Viktor Orban has already tarnished his reputation in their voters' eyes by his ill-fated decisions and scandals. No matter which aspect of his party's agenda comes up in a conversation, the majority of voters immediately associate Hungarian politics with the person of Viktor Orban. This has eventually led to a drop in the popularity of Fidesz in independent polls. Therefore, he may relinquish his position for the benefit of his party so that Fidesz is still in contention for winning the upcoming elections. Indeed, Orban might have the strategic incentive to relinquish no sooner does the Tisza Party win the 2026 Hungarian elections, than he will be put on trial for treason, bribery etc... based on the legal investigations already ongoing. Needless to say, he seeks to prevent Tisza from winning and the only way to do so is to get his party into a better position without h...
Read more »

Euroexam Writing Test 1 - C1

-
Kép
TASK ONE: Transactional Writing For the last three weeks, you have had a job in a restaurant. Your contract lasts another three weeks, but you are unhappy with the job and wish immediately. Using the job description and your notes below, write a letter to your boss, Mr Toller, explaining that you would like to leave and requesting a reference. Write ca. 200 words Write your answer to this question on the Answer Sheet. Further guidance on the documents attached! My letter: https://1drv.ms/u/s!AgGDb8F-_bVz1xjvgy6o5tI_9iES?e=7XychS TASK TWO: Discursive Writing Choose only ONE of the following questions – 1, 2 or 3 Write ca. 200 words DO NOT answer more than ONE question. Write your answer to this question on the Answer Sheet . A Jobs and Careers Magazine has invited readers to contribute an article entitled Key Considerations for the School Leaver. Write an article for the magazine stating the issues that you feel are the most important for young people when they are deciding on a car...
Read more »